Product: Duncan Hines Pie Filling Clear all filters (0 of 7 reviews match)
filters
Seller:
Show
State:
Show
City:
Show
Product:
I have used Comstock cherry pie filling for about twenty years as the topping for a wonderful New York style cheesecake that I bake for the holidays. I have always been very pleased with the look of the topping. The cherries have been large and round and plump. They...
Read more
Anonymous
Anonymous

I noticed the Duncan Hines logo on the Comstock also when I purchased 2 cans of strawberry pie filling this weekend. When I open the cans they were disgusting, clear brownish,...

Product
Duncan Hines Pie Filling
I didn't like
  • Extremely poor quality pie fillings
#1419193
Reply to reviews

Just purchased two cans of Simply Peach Pie filling/Topping. No idea how big a pie this makes or how long to bake it or what temp. Took off the label thinking info was hidden on the back.. nope! All it says on the front is "open and serve"... no help since I want to...
Read more
4.3
Menomonie, Wisconsin
Product
Duncan Hines Pie Filling
I liked
  • Great tasting product
I didn't like
  • No directions on making pie with filling
#1397130
Reply to reviews
I recently bought the Cherry Pie Filling and I was very disappointed with the taste and consistancy. It's not the same product as Comstock Cherry Pie Filling and I will not buy again. Comstock used to be my favorite brand of pie fillings, but no longer! .
Read more
Anonymous
Ruth

I've had the same experience. I've tried a couple different Comstock Cherry Pie Filling products, but none are like the ones I've used for years. Yuck!

Anonymous
Karen

I just bought cherry and blueberry pie fillings to make cheesecake. The cherries were pale. I tasted it. They are horrible!!!! Blueberries, pastey and no taste. Wherever taste...

Product
Duncan Hines Pie Filling
#1003126
Reply to reviews
Show

Duncan Hines Pie Filling Review

Why is my pie filling brown dont think its supposed to be
Product
Duncan Hines Pie Filling
#926779
Reply to reviews
I always buy the pitted cherries in a can.. to make my cherry cream cheese pie..at least once a week..Lately there has been puts in some of the cherries.. My don chipped his front tooth on one.. Please try an get all the pits out of them becausecee do love the...
Read more
Anonymous
Denise Fleischacker 123

Your wilderness cherry pie filling has pitts in it every time I make a pie I have to watch for Pitts when eating it and warn my guests. Think I will be checking for a new bran...

Product
Duncan Hines Pie Filling
#922300
Reply to reviews
I made a cherry pie and when I started eating a piece of it I bit into a cherry pit. Thank God I didn't break a tooth. It seemed like a good idea at the time to make this pie. I had a problem before, but it was because there was not enough quantity of cherries in...
Read more
4.7
Product
Duncan Hines Pie Filling
#818219
Reply to reviews
Comstock cherry pie filling used to be very good. Now there are very few cherries and mostly high fructose corn syrup. We used to make an 8-inch pie with one can. Now we wash off the syrup from the cherries of one can and mix them with the contents of a second can....
Read more
Anonymous
Li

I agree. I was in a hurry to make our Christmas pie and relented to using the Comstock like my hubby's mom used to. However, this filling tastes very bland and was not treat a...

2.0
Product
Duncan Hines Pie Filling
I didn't like
  • Poor quality of pie filling
#590117
Reply to reviews